You are 35. The formula says your max heart rate is 185 bpm. Garmin builds your zones on that number. Your training app plans your season around it. Your coach tells you to hold intervals at “90% of max, so 166.”

The problem is that you are not a statistical 35 year old. Your real HRmax could be 200 bpm. Or 172. The formula has about as much precision as being told the national average salary and asked to guess your own.

Max heart rate is one of the most important numbers in triathlon, because every training zone you use is built from it. And the most popular formula in the sport has been producing systematic errors for decades. Here is where it came from, why it fails, and how to find your real number.

“220 minus age”: how the myth began

The 1970s. Samuel Fox and William Haskell, working with Naughton, analysed data from exercise stress tests. They plotted age against HRmax, fitted a straight line that described the data “roughly,” and published it.

The formula was never built as a tool for athletes. It was an approximation for cardiologists doing population-level research, set arbitrarily from a handful of studies. The authors themselves said later that if they had known it would end up in mainstream use, they would have spent more time on the methodology.

The numbers are unforgiving. The formula’s standard deviation is 10 to 12 bpm. Cover two standard deviations, which spans 95% of the population, and the error margin is ±20 bpm, a 40 bpm spread for any given athlete. The rest of the variation comes from genetics, training history, heart volume and individual physiology. One formula cannot capture that.

Better formulas (still only estimates)

Researchers have spent 40 years trying to build a better formula. Three worth remembering:

Tanaka (2001): HRmax ≈ 208 minus (0.7 x age)

Built from a meta-analysis of 351 studies covering 18,712 people, validated against a further 514 participants. For a 35 year old: 183.5 bpm. The most cited formula in the scientific literature today.

HUNT (2013): HRmax ≈ 211 minus (0.64 x age)

From the Norwegian HUNT Fitness Study, 3320 healthy adults tested in 2007 to 2008. For a 35 year old: 188.6 bpm. It performs better for active people over 40, where “220 minus age” systematically underestimates.

Gellish (2007): HRmax ≈ 207 minus (0.7 x age)

For a 35 year old: 182.5 bpm. Close to Tanaka’s number, built from a longitudinal analysis.

What does this tell you? The newer formulas are statistically better, but for you, one specific triathlete, they are still an estimate with roughly a ±10 bpm error. No formula can tell you whether you are the outlier who sits 20 bpm off the average, and in an athletic population there are plenty of outliers.

How to actually measure HRmax

The only method that gives you your number is a test to exhaustion. You have three options, from clinical to field-based.

1. Lab test (the gold standard)

A metabolic cart, a treadmill or ergometer, a mask over your face. A technician raises the load every one to three minutes until you break down. Your heart rate in the last 30 seconds is your HRmax. The upside: precision to about ±2 bpm, and you get VO2max, metabolic thresholds and running economy in the same session. The downside: cost, roughly $110 to $190 in Poland (sports clinics and physiology institutes in the bigger cities), and 60 to 90 minutes of your time.

2. Field-based running test (practical)

A classic protocol for triathletes:

  • Warm up 15 minutes, easy jog in zone 1 to 2, then build to zone 4 over the last 3 minutes
  • Run uphill for 3 to 5 minutes at a pace you can barely hold, roughly your 10k race pace plus 10%
  • Jog 2 minutes back down
  • Run uphill again, this time sprinting the last 60 seconds until you are close to standing still
  • Note the peak reading from your watch over the last 30 seconds

Most triathletes hit 95 to 97% of their true HRmax with this protocol.

3. A 5k race

An equally good option. Race a 5k all-out with a hard sprint over the final 300 metres. In the last kilometre your heart rate should come very close to your HRmax. The condition is that you actually race it flat out, not at a comfortable “90% effort.”

Warning: never run this test if you have a heart condition, uncontrolled high blood pressure, or have had COVID in the last three months without clearing it with a doctor first. A maximal heart rate test is a genuine cardiac load.

What about HRmax for cycling and swimming

Here is the part that gets little attention: HRmax is discipline-specific.

On the bike, you typically hit an HRmax 5 to 10 bpm lower than on the run. The reason is that cycling does not require you to be upright, so less of your body mass needs to be moved with every stride. Lower demand on blood flow, lower peak heart rate.

In swimming, HRmax can run 10 to 15 bpm lower still than your running number. The horizontal position, water pressure on the chest and the cooling effect of the water all reduce peak heart rate. Calculating your swim zones from your running HRmax is a mistake that lands you in the wrong ranges entirely.

Best practice: run two separate tests, one on the run and one on the bike. For the pool, base your zones on effort and pace (CSS), not heart rate.

Verdict

“220 minus age” is fine as a rough starting estimate when you are new to the sport. It is not a sound basis for the zones you will train in for months. If your zones are built on a wrong HRmax, every session you do is off: too slow in your intervals, too fast in your base work, or the reverse.

Close the spreadsheet with the formula in it, lace up your shoes, and run the test on the nearest hill. Thirty minutes of work gives you data you can use for the next five years.

The next piece of the same puzzle is AirPods Pro 3 and Strava: Ear Heart Rate vs a Chest Strap. When the training is ready for a start line, Racelify lists triathlons worldwide.